
Does SICK OF IT ALL Have A Future Without LOU KOLLER? That's Something You 'Have To Just See What Happens', Says CRAIG SETARI
November 18, 2026In a new interview with "Reckless" Rexx Ruger of Pod Scum, bassist Craig Setari of New York hardcore legends SICK OF IT ALL spoke about the passing of the band's singer Lou Koller in July after a long battle with an esophageal tumor. He was 59 years old. Craig said (as transcribed by BLABBERMOUTH.NET): "It's a sad thing. He was my brother. And it's almost surreal, but it is real. And we all come and we all go, and this is the nature of life. And, basically, you have to just accept it and try to continue on. It's a tough thing. I think about him every day, and I think I'll take my hat off any time his name's mentioned for as long as I live.
"I said this when I spoke at his services. Could he possibly have lived a more full life?" Craig continued. "The guy lived a really full life. We went all over the world. We expressed ourselves to people. People gave us feedback. I mean, honestly, we were so blessed.
"You gotta think about it as the glass is half full and look at the positive end of it because there is a really positive end," Setari added. "The guy communicated with the entire world. People love us and respect us. He's respected and missed. And that's the way I choose to look at it, and it helps me."
Addressing a comment made in September by Lou's brother, SICK OF IT ALL guitarist Pete Koller, that Lou wanted the band to "keep going" after his death, Craig said: "Well, yeah. [Lou] had expressed that, hey, we all put in so much work. Everyone else went, got jobs with pensions and went to college, and we chose to do this. So he was, like, 'You guys should continue. You shouldn't let it go. This is what we do. This is who we are.' And that was how he expressed himself during his ordeal. And we said, 'Don't worry. You just worry about getting better and being comfortable.' But that's a possibility. We haven't talked at length about it yet. It's still too soon, and the wound is still too fresh. So, we've a little bit said a few things, but nothing is solidified at this point. But there is a possibility that at the very least something or other may happen at some point. But we don't really know, honestly."
Reflecting on the overwhelming amount of support Lou and the rest of SICK OF IT ALL received from the hardcore community in the wake of the singer's cancer diagnosis, Craig said: "It was incredible, the amount of love and support that came out of this. I really never realized how much this band and Lou and the individuals were appreciated until that happened. And it was special, and I think about that as well, and that makes me feel good in the sense that, at the time, we didn't really realize there was that much love involved in what we had created. But now we see that. And it's funny because Lou — he never said this, but I could see Lou now being, like, 'Rolling Stone wrote something about us? They never wrote anything about us when we were playing. Why the hell are they writing it now?' He would grump about that, and it makes me laugh to think about that. But it's a kind of thing, when you look at the body of work retrospectively, people give us the credit we deserve for, honestly, putting out so much so consistently for so long and to a large degree being pioneers amongst the other pioneering bands in this genre of music, which I feel is really important. I feel like it was one of the last great youth movements that was truly organic, the New York hardcore scene. So, I feel a lot of pride in what we've done, and I feel a lot of accomplishment. And as sad as this is, there's so much that was done along the way that that's what makes it sad in a sense, but that's what also makes it very memorable and glorious. That's also what helps, you know what I mean? The fact that we can all listen back to these records and read the words and remember how they affected us, and you can see the lyrics that we have, in everyday life, you can deal with it every day."
Asked if he thinks SICK OF IT ALL can exist as a band and keep going with a different vocalist, Craig said: "That's nothing you can really plan. That's something you just have to just see what happens. One of Lou's requests was that we play a free show for all the people that donated for him in some capacity, pretty much with different singers coming up and joining us — friends from the scene and bands that we came up with and friends we made along the way. So, that is one of the things that [we are talking about doing]… [There is] no venue booked for that, and there were just some ideas floating around. Nothing is locked in. And that was one of Lou's requests — continue and play a free show for everyone that came to help me when this happened."
Craig went on to say that he admired Lou's courage and took note that he didn't feel sorry for himself or bemoan his fate.
"The way Lou handled himself through this, that's what'll bring me to tears more than anything," the bassist recalled. "The man was so dignified and so accepting. I mean, Lou was the kind of guy, in our way of joking around, 'cause we had a really good, funny bone in the band. He would complain about the sandwich he had for lunch, or his cup of tea went cold or how Armand parked the van too close to the car behind him. And he'd complain about that, and it was, like, half a joke, but he was the kind of guy, and he proved it, if I said, like, 'Hey, Lou, we have to climb that mountain right now. It's gonna take us this long, and it's almost impossible,' he'd be, like, 'Yeah, let's go.' So Lou was a soldier. So, he complained about little things to just get a little relief, but, boy, did he handle himself with dignity through this. He never felt sorry for himself, and he was an inspiration. And I think about that, and that gives me goosebumps more than anything, the way he carried himself, the way the man carried himself. He was a glorious guy."
Lou announced in September 2025 that his cancer had returned just four months after celebrating being declared cancer-free.
When Lou first announced that his cancer had returned, he said in a video message: "I was having a really hard time with my recovery. I was having a tough time gaining weight and keeping food down. So I had some scans done, and sure enough, [the cancer] is back. But we're gonna take it day by day and see what happens."
A benefit concert supporting Lou's battle with esophageal cancer was held on November 23, 2024 at Irving Plaza in New York City. The "I'm In The Fight With Lou" event featured performances by VISION OF DISORDER, LIFE OF AGONY and MUNICIPAL WASTE, as well as veteran New York hardcore acts KILLING TIME and CROWN OF THORNZ.
After Lou went public in late June 2024 with the news that doctors discovered a cancerous tumor in his esophagus, Pete Koller set up a GoFundMe campaign to help cover some of the costs of his cancer treatment and assist with living expenses while the group is off the road and unable to tour. That campaign has since raised more than $380,000, with fellow artists AFI, RANCID and DROPKICK MURPHYS contributing $5,000 apiece, and bands such as SNAPCASE and HOT WATER MUSIC also making generous donations.
The long-running New York hardcore band subsequently canceled its previously announced European tour dates.
When Lou first posted about the diagnosis on social media, he said: "[Doctors] found a tumor in my esophagus that goes into my stomach, and I'll have to be getting treatment all summer — and of course, with full support of the band. As soon as they heard it, they were, like, 'Forget the tour. Just get healthy.' … They're all behind me staying home and us staying home."
Koller ended the message by saying: "I'll hopefully beat this thing and see you at the end of the summer … or maybe the winter."
SICK OF IT ALL's European tour was supposed to kick off in the Czech Republic on July 4, 2024.
SICK OF IT ALL's latest album, "Wake The Sleeping Dragon!", was released in November 2018 via Century Media.